Scarsdale Diet Support Site

Home
Beginner TIPS
Basic Rules
The Scarsdale Diet
Keep-Trim Eating
Two-On, Two-Off
Lifetime Keep-Slim
Daily Weight Chart
The Top FAQ's
Shopping List
Portion Sizes
Fruit
Vegetables
Protein Bread
Meat & Poultry
Fish and Seafood
Cheese & Dairy
Beverages
SF Candy & Gum
Substitutions
Switching Meals
Hungry? Legal Extras
Feeling Tired?
Cheating
Stalling & Gaining
Recipes
Member Recipe Ideas
Cooking Tools
Exercise
Nutrition & Calories
Low-Carb Transitions
White Flour & Sugar
The Good Carbs
Supplements
Health & Diet Links
Ketosis
Vegetarian Diet
International Diet
Money-Saver Diet
Gourmet Diet
About the Dr. & Diet
Success Stories!
Substitutions

What is permissible to change?

Basic Rule #1
1. Eat exactly what is assigned. Don't substitute.
 
Use your best judgement and refer to the basic rules to help you stay on the diet.
  • Meat protein can be substituted with a chicken, turkey, fish, shellfish, or veggie protein (see the vegetarian link for a list,
    for any lunch or dinner meal.
  • Poultry protein can be substituted with a fish, shellfish, or veggie protein, for any lunch or dinner meal.
  • Vegetables listed can be substituted with a similar veggie if allergies or unavailability prevents you from having what is listed.
  • Grapefruit may be replaced any day by fruit in season (read fruit link)
"Q: Are there no substitutes whatsoever permitted on the diet? Suppose I cant get one of the foods listed?
A: In one form or another, this is probably the most frequently repeated question. While it may seem like splitting hairs to some, I think it is important to follow the diet as written. Your attitude toward a diet is an important ingredient in the success or failure of that diet for you. When you start playing fast and loose with it, youre on your way off the Diet. (p.32)
 
"Of course, as I have said elsewhere in this book, common sense is also an important ingredient in the SMD. If, for some reason, you are stymied and cant get the spinach or zucchini that is called for that day, then obviously the sensible thing to do is to substitute a similar food from another day". (p.33)
 
One of the greatest features of this diet is that everything has been carefully planned out for you. You are supposed to simply follow the diet as written, and not make any substiutions, for the plan to work most effectively.
 
However, many members are always looking for ways they can change the diet and make it their own!
 
Keep in mind that once you start changing things around, it can be difficult to be strict and disciplined when you need to.
 
"Q: Im allergic to grapefruit , and I hate zucchini. Do I have to eat it if I dont like it?
A: Same old question again in a slightly different guise. If youre allergic to grapefruit or anything else on the Diet, of course you dont eat it. As for not liking what is on the Diet, thats something else again. Obviously, you arent going to stay on a diet long enough to profit from it, if you gag every time you think about zucchini or green pepper, or whatever. By the same token, remember that part of the purpose of this Diet and, certainly and important aspect of its ultimate value to you, is that it should help you to change your eating habits. If youre going to give up some of those golden oldies, youre going to have to be developing enjoyment in new tastes. Teach yourself to like some of these foods, if you dont already". (p.34)
 

Members Suggest:
 
"I have substituted vegetable myself with good results. Just be sure to substitute something similiar for example as with the spinach, if you don't like it, use broccolli or some other dark green vegetable. Good luck to you" - Debbie
 
"No modifications that I know of. However I have made some of my own. I will use low cal dressing but I use it sparingly. I read the labels on everything I buy and I won't buy anything that has too much fat or too many carbs. When purchasing bread I buy whatever has the most protein and fewest carbs. If you keep any modifications in perspective and still lose weight then I figure there is nothing wrong with that. Some people say they are hungry on this diet but I have found that if I eat enough meat each day, the protein will sustain me. Common sense without justifying a way to cheat in a bad way works for me. Some people will justify in their heads that a small piece of cake or just one candy bar won't hurt them but I have
found that it does. After going without sugar and fat for so long I feel great and if I do take a little in I can really tell a difference in how I feel. The closer you stick with this diet the faster the weight comes off. Also the more excercise or activity you do in a day helps. This diet is pretty basic so I doubt any new products that are on the market today would make it as part of this diet. I have read the labels on Atkins products and I have found
Atkins to be too expensive. For example Atkins bread was $6 a loaf and it was very small. Natures Own has high protein bread for less than half that price and it's a bigger loaf. Nature's Own Healthline Wheat and Fiber bread has 6 grams of protein, 7 carbs and 60 calories. Even Nature's Own regular wheat bread was just as good on the label as Atkin's bread. So anyway I suggest reading the labels
and make an educated choice". - Debbie